Best Rye Sandwich Bread of 2025

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 8, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Rye sandwich bread is a delicious and healthy option for those who love a good sandwich. Made with a blend of rye flour and wheat flour, this bread has a unique flavor that sets it apart from other breads. It is also lower in gluten than traditional wheat bread, making it easier to digest for those with gluten sensitivities. Rye sandwich bread is perfect for creating classic deli sandwiches like pastrami or corned beef, as well as more creative sandwich combinations. Whether toasted or fresh, this bread is sure to elevate any sandwich to the next level.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Gourmet Market Jewish Rye Bread Cover#TOP 1
Gourmet Market Jewish Rye Bread
ftb score rating icon9.9
Stern's Bakery Rye Bread Cover#TOP 2
Stern's Bakery Rye Bread
ftb score rating icon9.8
Black Bull Baltic Rye Bread Cover#TOP 3
Black Bull Baltic Rye Bread
ftb score rating icon9.6

Top 10 Rye Sandwich Bread

#TOP 1

Gourmet Market Jewish Rye Bread

Gourmet Market Jewish Rye Bread Cover
Jewish Rye Bread Pack of 4
ftb score rating icon9.9
FTB Score

Gourmet Market Rye Bread is a pack of 4 half loaves of pre-sliced 16 oz Jewish Rye Bread by New York's Finest Bakery. This bread is favored by many famous delis and sandwich shops in NYC. It's perfect for sandwiches and accompanying any meal. Made with natural ingredients like white rye flour and wheat flour, this sugar-free bread is crafted in one of New York's top bakeries. Remember to refrigerate it and consume within 30 days or freeze any leftovers for later use.

What We Like
Pre-sliced convenience
All-natural ingredients
Long shelf life
#TOP 2

Stern's Bakery Rye Bread

1 Pound (Pack of 2)
Stern's Bakery Rye Bread Cover
Rye Bread | Delicious Sandwich Bread | Fresh Bread | Real Jewish Rye Bread | Kosher, Dairy & Nut Free | 16 oz Stern’s Bakery [2 Pack]
ftb score rating icon9.8
FTB Score

Stern's Bakery takes pride in their delicious pre-sliced rye bread, offering a gourmet experience for bread lovers. Made with the finest ingredients, this authentic Jewish rye bread is fluffy, flavorful, and perfect for a relaxed breakfast or on-the-go sandwich. It is freshly baked daily and packaged in a dedicated bread bag to ensure optimum freshness. The bread is kosher, dairy-free, nut-free, and soy-free, making it suitable for various dietary needs. Whether you're hosting a party or enjoying a holiday meal, this signature loaf of rye bread will enhance your dining experience. Stern's Bakery guarantees customer satisfaction, prioritizing excellent service and support.

What We Like
Delicious gourmet rye bread
Freshly baked and packaged for optimum freshness
Suitable for various dietary needs
#TOP 3

Black Bull Baltic Rye Bread

Black Bull Baltic Rye Bread Cover
Black Bull Baltic Rye Bread Pack of 2
ftb score rating icon9.6
FTB Score

The Gourmet Market Rye Bread comes as a whole loaf, allowing you to slice it to your preferred thickness. Its hearty and dense texture makes it ideal for pairing with a variety of foods, from cold cuts to smoked fish. You can enjoy it fresh for up to 45 days after shipping, or freeze it for up to six months for later use. Made in a top New York bakery, this bread is free from trans fats and is both egg and dairy-free, making it a healthier choice for your meals.

What We Like
Whole loaf for custom slicing
Long shelf life when frozen
Pairs well with many foods
Made with natural ingredients
#TOP 4

Delba Famous German Whole Rye Bread

Delba
10955
Delba Famous German Whole Rye Bread Cover
Delba Famous German Whole Rye Bread, 16.75 Ounce (Pack of 12)
ftb score rating icon9.5
FTB Score

Delba Famous German Whole Rye Bread is a pack of 12 Kosher certified rye sandwich breads. It is free of preservatives, cholesterol, lactose, and wheat. This high-fiber bread is a product of Germany.

What We Like
Kosher certified
Free of preservatives, cholesterol, lactose, and wheat
High in fiber
#TOP 5

Stern's Bakery Rye Bread 3 Pack

Rye Bread-3 Pack
Stern's Bakery Rye Bread 3 Pack Cover
Rye Bread - 3 Pack - 32 oz per Loaf | Delicious Sandwich Bread | Fresh Bread | Soft & Light Rye Bread | Dairy & Nut Free | Stern’s Bakery (3 Pack)
ftb score rating icon9.4
FTB Score

Stern's Rye Bread is your go-to choice for soft and fluffy sandwich bread. Enjoy a relaxed breakfast or a tasty sandwich on the go, thanks to its convenient pre-sliced loaves. This delicious bread is baked fresh daily, ensuring you receive the highest quality and flavor with every bite. Plus, it’s kosher certified and made in a nut-free facility, making it a safe option for families. Your kids will love the taste, making mealtime easier and stress-free. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, you can trust that any issues will be promptly addressed.

What We Like
Freshly baked daily
Kid-friendly flavor
Pre-sliced for convenience
Kosher and nut-free

S.Rosen's Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel

S. Rosen's
S.Rosen's Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel Cover
S.Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel (Case of 4 Loaves)
ftb score rating icon9.2
FTB Score

S.Rosen's Pumpernickel Bread is perfect for creating tiny sandwiches for your next party. The mini 2.5" square bread slices are ideal for appetizers. With 35 slices per loaf, each serving includes 5 slices, making it convenient for serving a crowd. Additionally, this bread is shipped once a week on Monday mornings, ensuring freshness when you order by Thursday. Enjoy the convenience of preparing delightful appetizers or tiny sandwiches effortlessly with S.Rosen's Pumpernickel Bread.

What We Like
Great for party sandwiches
Mini slices for appetizers
Convenient serving size
#TOP 7

Rudolphs Rye Bread Double Crust 32oz

Rudolphs
Rudolphs Rye Bread Double Crust 32oz Cover
Rudolphs Tiefenfurter (Farmers Rye bread double crust) 32oz
ftb score rating icon9.0
FTB Score

Rudolphs Double Crust Rye offers a delightful taste that enhances your meals. Made with premium whole grain rye flour, this bread features a crispy outer crust and a moist interior, making it perfect for sandwiches or toasting. It's a nutritious choice, packed with fiber and low in fat, helping you maintain a healthy diet. Plus, it's free from artificial preservatives and crafted in the traditional German style, ensuring you enjoy a genuine flavor. You can conveniently store it at room temperature for up to a week or freeze it for longer use, making meal planning easier.

What We Like
Rich flavor
High in fiber
No artificial preservatives
Long shelf life
#TOP 8

Gourmet Market Dark Rye Jewish Rye Bread

Gourmet Market Dark Rye Jewish Rye Bread Cover
Dark Rye Jewish Rye Bread Pack of 4
ftb score rating icon8.8
FTB Score

Gourmet Market Rye Bread Pack is a set of 4 half loaves of pre-sliced Dark Rye Jewish Rye Bread, each weighing 16 oz. This bread is favored by many famous delis and sandwich shops in NYC for making delicious sandwiches. It also serves as a perfect side for any meal. The bread is all-natural, sugar-free, and crafted in one of New York's top bakeries. Made from Dark Rye Flour, Wheat Flour, Salt, Sour-Dough Starter, & Water, this Jewish Rye should be refrigerated and consumed within 30 days or frozen if not used within that time.

What We Like
Pre-sliced convenience
All-natural ingredients
Sugar-free
#TOP 9

Jewish Rye Bread by Generic

Generic
Jewish Rye Bread by Generic Cover
Jewish Rye Bread Pack of 4
ftb score rating icon8.6
FTB Score

Generic Jewish Rye Bread offers a delightful experience for sandwich lovers. Each pack contains four convenient half loaves, pre-sliced for your ease. This authentic bread is the preferred choice for many renowned delicatessens in New York City, ensuring that your sandwiches taste just right. Additionally, it pairs well with any meal, enhancing your dining experience. Made from all-natural ingredients and sugar-free, you can enjoy this wholesome bread without any guilt. Just remember to store it in the refrigerator and consume it within 30 days, or freeze it for later use.

What We Like
Convenient pre-sliced loaves
Authentic New York taste
All-natural ingredients
Perfect for any meal
#TOP 10

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread

pack of 2
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread Cover
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread (Organic Whole Rye, 17.6 oz, pack of 2)
ftb score rating icon8.5
FTB Score

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread is a delicious and nutritious option for your daily meals. Made with organic whole rye, this bread is not only tasty but also high in fiber, making it a great choice for those looking to increase their fiber intake. Whether you enjoy it toasted or as a sandwich, this bread is sure to satisfy your cravings. With no preservatives added, you can enjoy the natural flavors and goodness of this bread without any guilt. Plus, it is kosher and Whole Grains Council certified, ensuring the highest quality. Try Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread and experience the convenience and benefits of a wholesome and flavorful bread.

What We Like
Delicious and nutritious
High in fiber
No preservatives
Buying Guide Image

What You Need to Know About Rye Sandwich Bread

What is Rye Bread?

Rye bread is a type of bread made with rye flour. It is typically denser and more flavorful than traditional white bread, and has a slightly sour taste due to the use of fermented rye dough. Rye bread is a staple in many European cuisines, and is becoming increasingly popular in the United States as well.

How to Choose the Best Rye Bread for Sandwiches

When it comes to choosing rye bread for sandwiches, there are a few key factors to consider.

First and foremost, you want to look for bread that is fresh and high quality. This means avoiding bread that is stale or has a past-due date. Fresh bread will have a nice crust and a soft, moist interior. It will also have a pleasing aroma and a rich, rye flavor.

Next, you want to consider the type of rye bread that is best for your sandwich. There are several different types of rye bread, including pumpernickel, light rye, and dark rye. Pumpernickel bread is made with a combination of rye flour and whole rye grains, and has a deep, robust flavor. Light rye bread is made with a higher proportion of wheat flour, and has a milder flavor. Dark rye bread is made with a higher proportion of rye flour, and has a more intense flavor.

When it comes to sandwiches, light rye bread is often the best choice. It has a mild flavor that pairs well with a variety of sandwich fillings, and it is also more versatile than other types of rye bread. Light rye bread can be used for savory sandwiches, such as deli sandwiches or grilled cheese, as well as sweet sandwiches, such as PB&J or banana and honey.

Other Factors to Consider

In addition to the type of rye bread, there are a few other factors to consider when choosing the best rye bread for sandwiches.

First, you want to consider the texture of the bread. Rye bread is typically denser and more chewy than white bread, so it may not be the best choice for sandwiches that require a delicate texture, such as egg salad or tuna salad. However, rye bread is perfect for sandwiches with hearty fillings, such as roast beef or pastrami.

Second, you want to consider the nutritional content of the rye bread. Many rye breads are made with whole grains, which are a good source of fiber and other nutrients. Look for rye bread that is high in fiber, and try to avoid breads that are made with refined flour or have a lot of added sugar.

Finally, you want to consider the price and availability of the rye bread. Some specialty rye breads can be expensive, so if you are on a budget, you may want to look for more affordable options. Additionally, not all grocery stores carry rye bread, so you may need to shop at a specialty bakery or online to find the best rye bread for your sandwiches.

In Conclusion

When it comes to choosing the best rye bread for sandwiches, there are a few key factors to consider. Look for fresh, high-quality bread with a pleasing aroma and rich rye flavor. Choose a type of rye bread that is versatile and pairs well with your sandwich fillings, such as light rye bread. Also, consider the texture, nutritional content, and price of the bread to find the best option for your needs. With these tips, you can choose the perfect rye bread for your sandwiches.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is rye bread the healthiest?

Rye bread is considered more nutritious than wheat bread. It is high in iron, potassium, calcium, zinc, and soluble fiber. Rye bread is also more filling and contains more fiber and B vitamins compared to wheat bread.

2. What goes well on rye bread?

Rye bread pairs well with various toppings. Some popular options include Polish cottage cheese, Camembert, Chavroux, Maroilles, Bouton de Culotte, as well as meats like sobrassade, salchichon, Bayonne ham, and Jamón Ibérico de Bellota. It also goes well with fish such as anchovies and smoked salmon.

3. Do you toast rye bread?

Yes, you can toast rye bread until it becomes dry and slightly crispy.

4. Is rye bread better for you than white bread?

Rye bread, including sourdough varieties, is generally healthier than white bread. It has up to four times the fiber of white breads, making it a more nutritious option. Rye bread is also considered a wholegrain bread, which adds extra nutritional value.

5. What are the disadvantages of rye bread?

Some potential disadvantages of rye bread include the presence of antinutrients, which may interfere with nutrient absorption. It can also cause bloating in some individuals. Rye bread is not suitable for a gluten-free diet, and some varieties may be high in added sugar.

6. Is rye bread OK for weight loss?

Rye bread can support weight loss due to its high fiber content, which helps regulate bowel movements and promotes digestive health. Including rye bread in a balanced diet can be beneficial for weight management.

7. How do Germans eat rye bread?

In German cuisine, rye bread is a staple and is often enjoyed with cold meats, cheese, frikadelle, schnitzel, or served alongside soup.

8. What cheese goes with rye?

Cheddar cheese pairs well with rye bread and can be a tasty combination. Parmesan cheese can also be used to make cocktail party bites on rye bread. The choice of cheese can vary depending on the flavor and type of rye bread.

9. Does rye bread taste like normal bread?

Rye bread has a mild flavor that is nutty, earthy, and slightly malty. It is similar to whole wheat flour but with a fresher taste. Rye bread can be paired with fruits, spices, chocolate, and nuts for a delicious combination.

10. Is rye bread a good or bad carb?

Rye bread contains a similar amount of total carbohydrates as wheat bread, around 48g per 100g. However, the higher fiber content in rye bread means it has fewer net carbs compared to regular bread. While it is not a keto-friendly option, it can be included in a balanced diet.

Editor's Notes

During our rye sandwich bread research, we found 24 rye sandwich bread products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 6,807 customer reviews through our big data system to write the rye sandwich bread list. We found that most customers choose rye sandwich bread with an average price of $29.71.

The rye sandwich bread are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of rye sandwich bread, including Gourmet Market, Stern's Bakery, Delba, S. Rosen's, Rudolphs. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 329 consumers with an average rating of 4.5.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!